by Len Weiler
The new movie, The Piano Lesson, is a film adaptation of the playwright August Wilson’s Pulitzer Prize winning stage drama of the same name, which originally premiered in 1987. The play is amazing and the new movie is damn good as well. Taking us into the heart of a 1930s African-American family as it struggles with past demons and future aspirations, it is gripping, emotionally charged and thrillingly dramatic - while also nuanced, empathetic and sweet. The Piano Lesson just opened in theaters and will soon be available for home viewing as well (see below).August Wilson dropped out of high school when he was sixteen. Nothing was handed to him. As a playwright, he was self-taught. And still, he produced some of the strongest, most enthralling, literate plays produced by any American in the twentieth century. All of his work contains echos of the racism that has always been part of the African American experience. But it encompasses so much more as well.
Wilson wrote The Piano Lesson as part of a series of ten plays set in Wilson’s hometown of Pittsburgh, PA, which have become known his Pittsburgh Cycle – a.k.a. the Century Cycle, as each play has been set in a different decade of the 20th century - starting with the 1900s [i.e. the “oughts”] through the 1990s. The Piano Lesson is the fifth of these plays that Wilson wrote, but the fourth chronologically in the cycle, taking place in 1936.
It is also the third picture in the cycle to be produced by Denzel Washington, following Fences (2016), in which Denzel also starred, and Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom (2020). He plans to produce films based on each of the remaining seven plays in the cycle as well. Denzel does not appear in The Piano Lesson, but it is executive produced by his daughter Katia; directed by his youngest son Malcolm, who also co-wrote the screenplay; and stars his oldest son John David Washington [Tenet (2020), BlacKkKlansman (2018)]. So it is quite a family affair. The Piano Lesson also stars Danielle Deadwyler [Station Eleven (2011-12), Till (2022)], Samuel L. Jackson [Pulp Fiction (1994), The Last Days of Ptolemy Grey (2022)] and Ray Fisher [Zack Snyder’s Justice League (2021)].
The story takes place in a house owned by Doaker Charles (Jackson). His brother’s daughter Berniece Charles (Deadwyler) also resides there along with her eleven-year-old daughter Maretha [Skylar Aleece Smith], having moved to Pittsburgh from Mississippi a few years ago. In the parlor of the Doaker house is an old piano, also from Mississippi, which has been bound up tragically with the history of the Charles family since their ancestors were slaves there.Out of the blue one day, Berniece’s brother Boy Willie (J.D.Washington) and his friend Lymon (Fisher) show up unannounced at the Doaker house, with a truckload of watermelons they plan to sell in the city to get some cash. The other reason for their visit is the piano.
Boy Willie, a cocksure motormouth if ever there was one, sees himself as practical and ambitious. He says he has an opportunity to buy what remains of the plantation where his ancestors were enslaved. Wouldn’t that be something? He’s just a sharecropper now, but as a landowner he’d be somebody. And the land is just a start: with it, he can prosper, build-up some wealth and be his own man, self-sufficient. The thing is - Boy Willie needs to sell the piano to get the money.
Berniece doesn’t see it that way. The piano is our heritage and our legacy, she says, a manifest connection to our past, defining who we are and will be. The Sutters - the Charles family's white enslavers back in the day, acquired that piano by selling off Berniece and Boy Willie’s grandparents. Sometime later, their great-grandfather carved images of his enslaved wife and family onto the piano as a remembrance. Later still, their father was murdered for stealing it from the Sutters. As the film’s promo declares: “Blood is a chord that resonates through time.” Keeping the piano in the family is more important than a pie in the sky scheme to buy some land in the racist South, Berniece says. And she will not consent to sell it, no matter what Willie Boy thinks he can do with the money. Key historical events from 1911 Mississippi, which in the play are revealed exclusively via “present day” dialogue, are rendered via flashbacks in the movie, and there are a couple of scenes in a nightclub. But most of the action in The Piano Lesson takes place in Doaker’s house, mostly in the front parlor (where the piano resides), with a few scenes in the kitchen or upstairs rooms; and there’s no mistaking that we're seeing a cinematic rendering of a play. So yes, it is “stagey” – but in a good way. Like having the best seats in the house at a theatrical production – one with terrific actors giving awesome performances.The consensus, with which I fully agree, is that Deadwyler’s is the most magnetic and brilliant, the emotional center of the film. Whenever she’s around – which is most of the time - she is riveting. I'm anticipating numerous nominations for best actress awards. J.D. Washington is also great, but his character is difficult to like, so it takes awhile to appreciate what a good job the actor is doing. Fisher’s Lymon is a bit comical and also sweetly naïve. The other supporting players are solid as well.
Denzel Washington has said of Wilson: “His stories are specifically African American stories, But the themes are universal. Families, love, betrayal, whatever the theme is. [All] people relate to this.” And he is right. While this is a movie with an exclusively Black ensemble – other than briefly in the 1911 segment, I can’t recall a single white face – it’s a movie for everyone.
Wilson, looking back on his accomplishments, noted that hardship (which we all face one way or another) is the essence of all human drama. I especially like this quote: I once wrote this short story called ‘The Best Blues Singer In The World’, and it went like this – "The streets that Balboa walked were his own private ocean, And Balboa was drowning". End of story. That says it all. I've been rewriting that same story over and over again. All my plays are rewriting that same story.
There is no body of water in The Piano Lesson (other than the truckload of melons), but there is the sense that drowning is a real possibility. Berniece is still grieving her dead husband. She recalls her mother grieving the brutal murder of her husband (Berniece and Boy Willie’s dad). Lyman really wants to connect with a good woman, but he doesn’t know how. He and Boy Willie only recently got out of the clink and both their future prospects are uncertain, to say the least. The great depression has eased, but not by a lot. Life is tough.And I haven’t even mentioned the ghosts.I strongly recommend The Piano Lesson. Great writing. Great performances. A boldly dramatic story. Strong direction. It’s just a very solid, absorbing, intelligent and entertaining picture.
2 hours 5 minutes PG-13
Grade: A
Currently in select theaters nationwide. Begins streaming on Netflix on November 22, 2024.