Jafar Panahi’s Taxi [a.k.a. Taxi Tehran] (2015): A Great
Ride
You may recall my admiring review a year or so ago of This
Is Not A Film, the very personal documentary/memoir by, about and featuring
Iranian filmmaker Jafar Panahi, following his 2010 conviction for “propaganda
against the Islamic Republic,” as he attempts to deal with the conditions of his
probation. Among other things, Panahi
was banned from making or directing movies, writing screenplays or even giving
interviews, until 2030. As a viewing of This Is Not A Film makes clear, working
in cinema for Panahi is as essential as the air that he breathes – so such a proscription
on moviemaking amounted to stealing not only his livelihood but his life’s
purpose. He literally risked his life to make that (not a) film, and since then
has made two more besides.
Closed Curtain (2013), was/is an arty, allegorical, somewhat cryptic movie shot (surreptitiously) entirely within Panahi’s seaside villa in a magical realism style. It’s about the director’s struggle to come to an understanding between his legal circumstances and his need to create.
Jafar Panahi’s Taxi (2015), the subject of this
review, was shot entirely within a taxicab, using three minicams and an iPhone.
Panahi, the unemployable director, is the cab driver. The picture is literally a
journey - one that starts with the dashboard camera facing forward, providing a
view, through the windshield, onto a Tehran street with its traffic,
pedestrians and so forth; then the light turns green, and the taxi begins to
move. A soft soundtrack of traditional music kicks in – of a type often used to
accompany Persian epic poetry. Over the next eighty minutes, we ride along
with Panahi as he picks up various passengers and they engage in several interesting,
seemingly random conversations, sometimes with one another and sometimes with
the cabbie/director. This journey is not about the places we visit, but rather
the people we meet and the world that they and Mr. Panahi inhabit.
I know, that doesn’t sound like much, yet believe me: this
movie is a small, lustrous wonder - a seemingly uncomplicated little film, yet
one that that stays with you, makes you smile with appreciation and which, upon
reflection, turns out to be deep and layered. The tone throughout is light; the
undertone, not so much. Taxi is by turns
engaging, revealing, funny, wise, provocative and always deeply human. Like the
two previous films, Taxi was shot clandestinely; also like those
pictures, it has been banned in Iran.
I think this movie is an understated masterpiece. I am not
alone in my appreciation: last year Taxi won top prize at the Berlin
International Film Festival, the Golden Bear. It’s as if the constraints within
which Panahi is forced to work have necessitated a level of subtlety and
creativity that have elevated his art.
The passengers in Panahi’s taxi are too numerous and various
to describe in any detail here. And part of the fun is discovering them as they
enter the cab and reveal a bit of themselves. Highlights include a
self-described “mugger” and a schoolteacher, who get into a spirited debate
about crime and punishment. There’s a black market DVD supplier (who, not
unreasonably, sees himself as performing a public service), and a film student
who asks Panahi for advice, because he can’t come up with a subject for his
first short film. The director sagely replies that a filmmaker has to find that
for himself.
Not stuck for ideas is Panahi’s delightful niece, Hana, a
bright, charming, vivacious young girl (perhaps 11?) who also has a short movie
assignment for school. She finds subjects in pretty much everything she sees,
and is shooting video constantly. When Panahi briefly leaves the taxi to run an
errand, Hana points her little camera out the window, capturing a bridal gown
bedecked wife and her bridegroom walking to their getaway car (shadowed by an
omnipresent videographer, just like here), and a young scavenger boy absconding with a
money clip that the groom has inadvertently dropped. Later, she describes
documenting “from A to Z” the story of star-crossed young lovers facing angry opposition
from the girl’s family because the boy is Afghani. Hana’s problem is not lack
of subject matter; it’s that none of the real life video vignettes she has recorded
will be acceptable - because her project must meet the distribution standards
for all Iranian films, and those standards ban, among many other things, the depiction
of “sordid reality.”
Panahi himself, as driver, takes in everything with a
serene, tolerant smile, and Taxi treats all of these people, with their
contrasting lives and points of view, with great equanimity and compassion.
And we come to see them that way, as well. These Iranians are not some inscrutable
“other”; they’re a lot like us, trying to get by, to take care of their
families, trying to find happiness. They are also surprisingly entrepreneurial.
And appealingly polite.
In the manner of This Is Not A Film, this movie pretends
that is something other than it is - in this case, just a slice of life in
Tehran. In fact, Taxi explores a mix of interrelated themes, commenting
on the current state of Persian society and on the injustice of the treatment
of Panahi and other artists and intellectuals in his country. We see how the
country’s screwed up economy has impacted ordinary Iranians (scavenging, thievery, a rampant black market, a jaundiced
or pessimistic outlook on life). The film is also a kind of secular jihad, using
ridicule to attack many of the absurd rules of conduct emanating from the Islamic
thought police, by exposing them to the light of day. For one example, the Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance
dictates what a movie should include (for example, good guys should have
Islamic, not Persian, names and should not wear ties) and what is not allowed
(women with uncovered hair, criticism of Islam or of the government, depictions
of “sordid realism”, and so forth). Taxi
highlights the dichotomy between the airbrushed vision of Islamic society
preached by the governing religious establishment and the sordid reality of the
real world – where theft is rampant; where young people fall in love without
regard for family wishes; where widows often face destitution, because they presumptively
do not inherit from their husbands; where girls are arrested just for trying to
attend male sporting events (see Panahi’s excellent comedy-drama Offside
[2006]); where the justice system presses people to lie under oath to preserve
the mirage of an upright regime, and where, in fact, most people are secular.
Much of this information comes across through the comments
of the taxi’s “passengers” – all of whom are anonymous (and uncredited). Panahi
himself is not saying this stuff (wink, wink), he’s just the driver. But then,
we know that just making and distributing the movie was an act of political
defiance.
Jafar Pahani’s Taxi comes with my highest
recommendation.
82 minutes.
Available streaming on
Netflix, and from Amazon, iTunes, Google Play, and other sites.
Closed Curtain (2013) is available streaming from Amazon, iTunes, Google Play, YouTube, and
other sites
Offside (2006)
is available streaming from Amazon, iTunes, Google Play, YouTube, and other
sites; and on DVD from Netflix.
No comments:
Post a Comment